Coin Brief ENDE

Kusama set-reduction debate gets data: reports measure decentralisation and coretime impact

A post on the Polkadot forum on 4 November published two reports meant to inform the debate on reducing Kusama's validator set. Its author, Lederstrumpf, separates them from the strategy discussion in the existing proposal thread on adapting Kusama to demand and its JAM future: this thread is about method, and he asks for critical feedback on the findings.

The decentralisation report looks at how metrics changed with the last reduction and estimates how further reductions would affect them. It uses two measures: the Nakamoto coefficient, which the author describes as the number of operators that would have to be coerced or bribed to break Byzantine fault tolerance, and the Gini coefficient of seats across operators, alongside a breakdown of operators by size class. A second report covers coretime.

The hard part, the post says, is working out which validators share an operator, since many stashes have no on-chain identity. Readers can choose three levels of clustering heuristics, from conservative to "staking cabals", built on signals such as shared identities, payee accounts, proxy keys and closed nominator sets. Coverage reaches 90.4% of validators at the pragmatic level and 98.1% at the broadest.

The author says he was surprised that the last reduction did not worsen the relative mix of operator sizes. He also cautions that an improving Gini coefficient should be read carefully, because the largest operators roughly keep their share of seats.

Kusama set-reduction debate gets data: reports measure decentralisation and coretime impact
Kusama set-reduction debate gets data: reports measure decentralisation and coretime impact — Coin Brief

What it means

Set reductions are usually argued in terms of cost and coretime; this puts numbers on the decentralisation side before the next decision. The caveat about the largest operators is the one to watch, since a fairer-looking curve can hide a top tier that does not shrink.